editorial partner Liberte! Friedrich Naumann Foundation
Society

Magical Powers and Factory Settings of Poles

Magical Powers and Factory Settings of Poles

The authors write about the “factory settings” of the Polish people, transforming national flaws — stubbornness, outsized ambition, a penchant for makeshift solutions and “working the system,” a unique brand of egoism, and a knack for circumventing the state — into “magical powers.” In this view, what were once considered shortcomings become indispensable assets.

The 1990s: a typical housing estate, full of prefabricated concrete apartment blocks. A few guys got together in a makeshift metal shed… and suddenly, we had the internet in our homes. Sure, cables might have been dangling here and there, and the connection speeds of that era would make us smile today — but we had it at home, back when most people could only access it at school, work, or university.

Over time, those makeshift beginnings evolved into thriving businesses, turning those young men into serious entrepreneurs. It was the start of a story — the kind of story you find all over Poland. It’s a tale born from passion, but also from spotting a need — a gap that the state would take years to eventually fill. Poland is full of such stories: ventures that began in a brother-in-law’s garage, a parents’ basement, behind a barn, or simply during a casual chat — over a beer or a bit of gossip.

These are stories about how this distinct nation — for better or worse — has repeatedly found ingenious ways to outpace or bypass the thicket of institutional red tape, all to make life easier, streamline the everyday, and, in effect, push the country forward. Hanna Gil-Piątek and Bartłomiej Sienkiewicz write about these “magical powers” of the Polish people in their book, A Nation for Special Tasks (Naród do zadań specjalnych).

It is not just that I find myself smiling at these mechanisms — which are described here, yet are already so familiar — or that I follow the development of the authors’ thesis, page by page, with genuine pleasure; nor is it that I am already considering which of my friends or acquaintances might find a copy under their Christmas tree… (though all of that is true). Rather, it is about the recognition and articulation of a pattern we all know — for surely everyone has, at some point, taken part in such a “perfect guerrilla operation,” or, at the very least, cheered it on.

The fact is, we are a nation — or a society — of “perfect guerrillas,” of resourceful, informal fixers who, in a backyard shed or a garage, can cobble together solutions often superior and more effective than those achieved through official channels. These “operations” frequently outpace the state — with all its rigid “factory settings” — which the “perfect guerrilla” may occasionally stumble over, but has, time and again, managed to skillfully circumvent.

There is some truth to this, as “it seems that Poles, as part of their ‘factory settings,’ have perfectly mastered the practice of reaching beyond horizons deemed insurmountable. The parallel to other collective surges — albeit on a smaller scale, and driven by material needs or aspirations — is striking” (p. 47); furthermore, “irrationality does not in the least hinder [us] in the most pragmatic of undertakings” (p. 41).

In a somewhat similar vein — though with a more restrained writing style — a Conservative Liberal with the “mindset of a battalion commander” and a Left-wing Activist, who observes matters “from the inside,” have come together to write a book. They claim it emerged from their observations of everyday life — and their reactions to it, to the world as it exists, and to the world that has shaped our modernity. Their perspective is, on one hand, broader — reaching beyond the “here and now” — and, on the other, more granular; it places us — Poland and the Polish people — under a magnifying glass, specifically in our relationship or collision with the state. Crucially, as Bartłomiej Sienkiewicz has noted before, this is a state built “from the bottom up” — a reality that proves to be both a blessing and a curse for a “nation suited for special tasks.”

To shed light on this Polish horizon, the authors discuss the “factory settings of the Poles,” transforming national flaws — stubbornness, outsized ambitions, a reliance on makeshift solutions and cunning workarounds, a unique form of egoism, and an aptitude for circumventing the state — into “magical powers.” And so, shortcomings transform into assets — indispensable ones, at that. What emerges is a kind of “perfect guerrilla” approach: neighborhood networks (including the one in my own area), the electrification of the country, the Solidarity movement, and a multifaceted form of solidarity that we are capable of — not just on rare, momentous occasions, but as a matter of course.

Think of online aid platforms and targeted fundraising campaigns that we organize long before the state even stirs; the assistance provided to war refugees (again, despite a state that was woefully late to act); the vast scale of the Great Orchestra of Christmas Charity; or the countless smaller, grassroots initiatives — invisible to the central authorities — that generate real agency. This agency, in turn, forms the foundation for something far more profound than a simple, conventional definition of a “community.”

Perhaps we don’t even need such grand terms. It is, rather, a mechanism where, once a problem is identified, there is no need for institutional deliberation or mountains of paperwork —o nly concrete action. Action and reaction, problem and solution; direct engagement rather than beating around the bush. Hic et nunc — here and now. A web of connections. And yes, the authors are right: we function at our best when we run out of an instruction manual.

Yet, if things are going so well for us, why are they also so bad? The answer — and it is hard to disagree — is that “the foundational settings of Polish politics and the state are the greatest obstacle to the opportunities presented by the modern world, as well as those arising from the collective instincts of the Polish people” (p. 113). These “factory settings” apply to both sides: the people on one hand, and the institutions—broadly defined—on the other.

The problem, however, runs deeper than just the limited imagination of Polish politics; instead of moving toward modernity, it stubbornly clings to old, regressive patterns — patterns that, according to the authors, date back to a time when we (as a state or nation) were still in a phase of aspiration. Yet, even then, the ingenuity and initiative of the Polish people never quite fit into these institutional frameworks.

After all, how is one supposed to live without losing one’s temper, or take action without sighing in resignation, when “at every turn, the state — through the actions of its institutions —s eems to say: Don’t renovate that historic building, you’ll only ruin it. Don’t bother with grants; you don’t know how to handle the paperwork. Don’t try to generate your own electricity—we won’t let you anyway. And even when the state manages to do something right for once, it ‘improves’ it so thoroughly that everyone just loses the will to try” (pp. 187–188)?

The question remains: is it truly impossible — to such a profound and extreme degree — to reconcile these two orders? Or perhaps the question should be framed differently: what might the boundary conditions for such cooperation look like? What is it that prevents us, on one side, and the state, on the other, from simply “letting go”?

There is talk of procedures, so-called safety conditions, and even stifling, restrictive measures — yet, as the authors rightly point out, it is precisely the “collective, back-breaking toil of the Poles that has secured our current economic standing — to the surprise, and often the envy, of other nations. This is the daily reality for millions of Poles, both at home and among those working abroad” (p. 186). And yet, we keep tripping over institutional hurdles; the state views the grassroots agency of its citizens as a form of competition rather than an asset.

Consequently, instead of flourishing through supportive public structures, Polish innovation finds itself in a state much like our demographics: everyone desires change for the better, but it never quite seems to work out (p. 187). And so, we stumble again. Or worse — we turn away, resigned, because once more — time and time again — the system has proven too constrictive for the Polish people. It is not merely that it wasn’t “tailor-made” (no social contract could ever be perfectly bespoke); rather, it is simply too tight — like a corset that digs in, pressing uncomfortably against the heart. And it is hard to deny that this, indeed, is “Poland through and through.”

Another point… what is it that “holds us back” — this time, us as a state — where the public sphere fails to harness the potential of individual citizens or groups working “for” (the common good, development, or reform — take your pick)? What stands in the way of opening up this system and placing at least some trust in those who, through their own agency, restored our freedom and independence — for the second time (after 1918) — and, above all, in those who, in their own way, are willing and able to take matters into their own hands amidst the challenges of daily life?

What might loosen these “bonds” even a little? What could help us move past the habit — which, contrary to what the authors suggest, is no longer as widespread today — of defining ourselves primarily through the lens of “misfortune and suffering”? How can we disabuse the next generation of decision-makers of this notion of a uniquely “Polish fate” — a concept that young people increasingly reject, much as they reject the idea of ​​”fleeting enthusiasm”?

This new generation, focused on its own modest successes and smaller, tighter-knit communities, is less defined by such tropes. In this emerging “nation for special tasks,” there is little appetite for the fatalistic resignation of “all that’s left is a noose,” or the reckless, “let’s just charge ahead — it’ll work out somehow” mentality. Today, the concept of “magical powers” — the capacity to make things happen — takes on a new meaning.

For the rising generation, this agency often operates not in opposition to the state, but alongside it — with the simple, pragmatic hope that the state, at the very least, will not stand in the way of this “democratization of modernity.” For… the less they get in each other’s way, the more effectively they function — unobtrusively shaping something akin to the future. A future that acknowledges limitations but rejects rigid constraints — a future in which these “perfect partisans” prove to be an indispensable asset, an opportunity the state can no longer afford to miss.


The article was originally published in Polish at: https://liberte.pl/magiczne-moce/